Your Qna     New Questions     About Qna
EQNA is a growing interactive people-knowledge network with more than 120,000 questions and 450,000 answers from over 55,000 members worldwide. With all friendly functions, EQNA will be a fun place to join, share and discover knowledge, an open net space allowing you to connect with other people having specialized knowledge or ones with same interests to yours. EQNA login features secured logins using Twitter and Facebook enable you to place questions without sharing your personal information to us. Lets get out and join our community today!
Ask a Question
Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!

Do facts change minds? Or are minds already made up?"

Perhaps my question should be "What can cause you to change your mind?" But actually my purpose is not to change minds whenever I find questions and answers on Q&A that seem to me to be unsupported by the facts or misrepresented, I do some research and if I come across factual material to support an answer I usually cite my reference as being a "fact." However, my intention is not to change minds, but rather to "set the record straight," because I believe that for most people their minds are already made up, Do you agree?
One Twisted Child:

If someone can present me with credible, factual evidence to prove me wrong, I have no choice but to reevaluate my position. You have to keep an open mind, be willing to listen to opposing viewpoints, as well as facts that do not fit your opinion, in order to grow as an individual.

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

It's always a pleasure to read your answers because I believe they are sincere after you took my ego down a peg or two for over assuming your motives.

Kim:

B/A from me Twisted---good job:)
K

Trina:

Good point. There is a difference between; stubbornness and confidence that one's opinion is actually "true".

People do not like being proven "wrong"....and many do perceive "facts" that are not what they thought to be true as an attack on them personally. When it is simply what "really happened".

We all have an uncanny ability to morph and twist objective facts into subjective truths based on our own individual perceptions. Many issues get clouded with people using facts and wording them in such a way to prove THEIR point.

Minds do get made up....and arrogance and ego get in the way of "enlightenment" more often than not.

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

Thanks for your observation. You hit the nail right on the head --- "arrogance and ego." You are so right about people being so defensive to criticism. Many people take criticism too personal and do not understand its value. As a reporter early in my career, every thing I wrote went through a copy editor or managing editor's desk. I realized that grammatical, spelling and typing errors were fair game, but the first time my editor tossed a news story back to me with notes along the margins I got in a big huff of indignation. "What's wrong this?" I asked. " Read the notes," he snapped backed, and then sensing my busted ego, he said, "If I didn't like the story I could have just torn it up and tossed it. But I think it can be improved if you just write it from a different perspective." I got the message. "If something you do is worthy of criticism, it has value. Otherwise it's simple not worth even a comment.

Blogafter5:

HI FJA,
I don't agree. And I don't mind being wrong. It has been awhile since I have interacted on QnA, but I believe that most people come here to learn something, I do. Right or wrong, I love reading the ideas and opinions people express.

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

Perhaps your right in agreeing with my observation about "most people." Usually the facts that I offer to support those assumptions are the results of polling. For instance, while many people say they again abortion they still contend that it's personal right of a women to make a choice, despite the fact that abortion kills human life. I do agree that facts help us learn and to me that's also the most important thing I get from QnA participation. So thanks for your thoughtful observation.

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

Thanks for your answer. Your example of abortion rights vs pro-life is exactly one of the things that led to my conclusions. I sometimes think that you can you often tell when facts do change minds. That when, after presenting your facts the person responds, sort of humbly, "Oh, I never knew that" or "Where did you get you information?" In otherwords, they have no immediate rebuttal to what you have fact presented.

Checkthefacts:

One of the reasons salesmen make so much money is that they have one of the hardest tasks in human relationships--moving people out of a comfort zone. Minds that are "made up" can be changed, but often with much difficulty. Facts, in and of themselves, are usually not enough to change minds, because "facts" can frequently be molded to appear to be what they actually are not. People need a practical reason to change their mind, whether it is something as simple as an appreciation of and the ability to discern "the truth", for its own sake (an unfortunately an all too rare situation) or a realization that accepting the facts would put the person in a more advantageous position than sticking with the former "facts". A mind is a terrible thing to waste and an even more difficult thing to change.. Be blessed

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

Great point, but let's not forget that not every salesman has that difficult of a task. In most cases the consumers' minds are already made up, having been preconditioned by advertising that more often is just hyperbole or the use of facts in some distorted way. Perhaps even more to your point is the ability of the salesman to focus on what the consumer wants to hear not necessarily the facts. Hasn't the home mortgage crisis demonstrated that ? Consumer are often so gullible that they overlook the small print (the real facts) when the salesman hands them the pen and says, "Just sign here.!" I'm sure this has happened to you. I know it happens to me.

Checkthefacts:

I differentiate salesmen from order takers. Anybody can follow up on a preconditioned lead to simply take the order which has been presold by another marketer. The true salesman is illustrated in the story of two "salesmen" who went west to sell shoes. The first writes back to his wife, "I'm coming home they don't even wear shoes in this town." The second writes back to his wife, "Honey, I'm staying here for a while, they don't even wear shoes in this town" Same words, but not the same statement. Same title, salesman, but only one truly is.

The:

Most people make decisions, and make up thier minds emotionally based upon thier own biases, experiences, and expectations and then seek only those facts that support that decision. We would all be better off if we could step back from our emotions and seek the facts, listen to both sides of an arguement, and make an informed decision.

Ze'_Enigma of Dissidence..!!!:

Thanks for your comment. As a general observation that's so true. Many people seem to have a "comfort zone" and no matter what the facts are they do fit into that zone. I don't think it's a question of denying the facts, but rather it's "uncomfortable" to change your mind.

Lyinn:

It depends on who your talking to. If you are talking to a liberal it's like talking to a child.

Takeru:

Showing me the facts on something does not necessary mean I will change my mind. Case in point. My sister in-law is pro life and I'm not pro life. She brought me stats on how abortion was done and how many abortion had been done since Roe vs. Wade. I am still pro choice and I believe in a woman'a right to choose.

Answer:
Text ColorBackground Color
BoldItalicUnderline
LeftCenterRightJustify
Ordered ListBulleted List
IndentOutdent
Horizontal Rule
SubscriptSuperscript
HyperlinkImage
Design ModeDesign
Html ModeHtml
 

Top Question And Answer

  • Does anyone know if there is a way to change the text to be more legible on Answerbag?
  • Do you think enormous amounts of money, would change you in some way?
  • HOW TO FIND MY FICTIOUS NAME LIST TO CHANGE
  • HELP! CAN'T UNLOCK MY MOTOROLA RAZR! LOST THE UNLOCK CODE! HOW DO I FIGURE IT OUT OR CHANGE IT!?!?!?
  • Did you guys know that Obama missed almost 40% of the Senate Votes. This is someone who wants change
  • Is it possible in Sharepoint 3.0 to request users change their password every 3 months? If yes How?
  • How do I change the setting to use my arrows on excel 2007. Currently arrow control the scroll bar
  • When people ask "Do You Have Spare Change ??? " Do you give them any ???
  • Do you agree that climate change is the greatest furphy inflicted on the public since the Y2K bug ?
  • If you've read, Guns,Germs,Steel: How has reading this book change your perspective on world history
  • The credit bureau's have the wrong SSN number for me, how do i change it?
  • have you seen loose change, the final cut just released? what did you think of it? watch for free...
  • im in charge of running a website that already exists (i know the pword) but i dont know how 2 login
  • Do you think we are already in a major recession or worst a mini depression?
  • Do you realize the North American Union already exists? Pretty soon Canada, US, and Mexico will be 1
  • How has or when will Nafta begin helping the US and in what way. Benefits seen by MX and CA already
  • Looking for an attorney that will take a case on contingency. The case is already prepared .
  • Woohoo!! i got half a star already!! :) Just wondering what do you think of me? see details.........
  • WSS 2.0 - Can't add a user to site. Message states user name already exists. Name does not show?
  • Ok time too get this show on the road. If you have read my other questions some of you already have?
  • how can i create a business that does not already exist from my home?
  • trying to find a free loan agreement form to have some one sign on a loan i already took out (help)
  • Would like to get status of passport renewal. Application number already given by NPIC.
  • i have a policy already in force and I would like to see about adding my sons car on our policy can
  • I want to buy a bag,what is the baghttp:www.goyardreplicasale.com/Grade-Quality-Goyard-Saigon-Tote-Bag-PM-8941-Black/196/index.html
  • How is it:www.topreplicagears.com
  • Www.mokahandbags .com
  • Facebook new account opening form
  • Hom bhr0165301533Www.facebook.new account
  • Hom bhr0165301533
  • Hom bhr0165301533Www.facebook.new account
  • Hom bhr0165301533
  • how do I get mms message fro. mmsweb.iwireless.com
  • Find out how many cars of my model are registered
  • What would happen if a letter opens in the mail
  • Facebook new account open
  • Facebook New Account Creation
  • Facebook new account creation
  • locating a business that closed